A plate and cup staying on a table while a tablecloth is yanked out fast

PHYSICS WORTH SHARING

This is the last full teaching week before Thanksgiving, and next week a lot of tables get a tablecloth and the good plates. Somebody always wants to try the tablecloth trick.

Pull the cloth slowly and the plates come with it. Yank it fast and the plates barely move. Friction pulls on the plates both times. What changes is how long it gets to act.

FREE THIS WEEK

Tablecloth Trick practice sheet (Units 1 and 2: Motion and Forces). New this week and built on the numbers in this issue. One printable page, six problems with clean answers on a = Fnet / m, Fnet = ma and a = (vf − vi) / t, plus a Think About It on why a smaller force can change the velocity more. Page 2 is the answer key, with a teacher note for the demo below. It is a direct download with no signup. Get the free Tablecloth Trick practice sheet

One quick question

One tap, so we know what to build for you next.

Last week's poll went to a quick review game for test day, so a free review game is coming in early December, just in time for finals review.

Why the plates stay put

The only sideways force on a plate is friction from the cloth. In the simple friction model, kinetic friction is μk·m·g, so a = Fnet / m = μk·g. The mass cancels, and a heavy plate and a light plate get the same acceleration.

Put in numbers. Say friction gives the plate about 3 m/s² (μk near 0.3, an example value). If the cloth is gone in 0.1 s, the plate reaches at most 3 m/s² × 0.1 s = 0.3 m/s and slides about 1.5 cm. Table friction then stops it within another centimeter or two.

A slow pull is different. If the cloth speeds up gently, static friction is strong enough to carry the plate along with the cloth. Keep pulling and the plates end up on the floor.

That is Newton's 1st Law (the plate stays at rest unless a net force acts) and the 2nd Law (the net force is small and brief, so the change in velocity is small) in one move.

Where students slip (ask these during the demo below)

1. "Fast is too fast for friction." Ask: "Does the coin feel any friction when the card shoots out?" Fix: yes. Kinetic friction is nearly independent of speed. Once the cloth slips, kinetic friction is a bit weaker than static friction, but the fast pull wins mainly on time.

2. "No force, so it didn't move at all." Ask: "Which way did the coin shift?" Fix: a little, in the direction the card moved. Friction acted briefly, so Δv = a·Δt is small but not zero.

3. "Heavier things are harder to drag, so heavy plates work better." Ask: "If friction doubles and the mass doubles, what happens to a?" Fix: a = μk·m·g / m = μk·g. In this model the mass cancels.

The coin-and-card test (run it Monday)

For: Unit 2 Forces, Newton's 1st and 2nd Laws. Time: 5–10 minutes. Materials: a plastic cup, an index card or playing card, and a coin for each group.

  1. Lay the card flat across the top of the cup and center the coin on the card, right over the opening.

  2. Slow trial: push the card sideways slowly with one finger. The coin rides along with the card and does not drop into the cup.

  3. Fast trial: reset, then flick the edge of the card sharply and straight sideways with your finger. The card shoots off and the coin drops into the cup.

  4. Have each group do 3 fast flicks and record how many times the coin lands in the cup.

Land it: friction from the card acted on the coin in both trials. In the slow trial it acted the whole time and carried the coin along. In the fast trial it acted for a fraction of a second, so the coin's change in velocity was tiny, and gravity took over once the card was gone. Then ask students to explain the tablecloth trick with the same words.

In case you scrolled past it: get the free Tablecloth Trick practice sheet.

Forward this to a colleague who is teaching Forces before the break.

Stay Wildly Curious — Lauren & Shawn

Reply

Avatar

or to participate